Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

  1. Open PRs
    1. Esmé will create a new PR incorporating agreed-upon language from https://github.com/fcrepo/fcrepo-specification/pull/137
  2. Andrew created issues for the differences between the SOLID guidelines and the current implementation.
    1. Will create a delta doc 
    2. Re: #163: Simeon will create a PR to add language about always having a Link rel="acl" and using the default
    3. Re: #166: Do we need WebIDs, or are any URIs enough?
      1. Any URI should be enough, dereferencing etc. are not required for WebAC to work
    4. Re: #168: Referencing ACLs/groups outside of the repository — we should add a non-normative note about this
      1. Maybe add an item to the security considerations section too?
    5. Re: #164: There is a note about webac:defaultForNew being renamed to webac:default, but not when
      1. Simeon will ask if/when this will be changed so we can know which we should use
    6. Andrew will start moving them forward — provide feedback on the issues before Friday
  3. Deletion
    1. We have agreed that recursive deletion isn't required, and headers should be used to indicate capability
    2. Sticking point is what does containment, and atomicity (should be handled in atomic operations spec)
    3. Ben will check with Hydra stakeholders about expectations for recursive deletion
    4. Danny will open a PR to add non-normative note about atomicity not being guaranteed, and that the Depth header should be respected
  4. Multiple implementations
    1. We should work towards cultivating other implementations, including aligning the Modeshape impl. with the spec, Cavendish, etc.
  5. Test suite
    1. Need to be able to run with different implementations in different languages, environments, etc.
      1. Don't want to conflict with Java projects' dependencies
      2. Don't want to require non-Java projects to setup Maven just to run the test suite
    2. Andrew will contact the contractors about scoping and specifying work

Action Items

    •  
  1. Simeon Warner to close out https://github.com/fcrepo/fcrepo-specification/issues/122 
    •  Esme: create a new PR incorporating agreed-upon language
    •  Andrew: create delta doc for WebAC changes
    •  Simeon: create PR addressing #163, adding language about always including Link rel="acl" header and using default
    •  Simeon: ask about timeline for updating webac:defaultForNew to webac:default - DONE https://github.com/solid/web-access-control-spec/issues/20
    •  Ben: ask Hydra stakeholders about recursive deletion expectations
    •  Danny: open PR to add non-normative note about atomicity not being guaranteed, and that the Depth header should be respected (not ignored)
    •  Andrew: work with contractors to scope and specify TCK work