This is a list of outputs from the LD4P, organized by type of deliverable. For detailed information on each project in LD4P, see the individual Project Pages. Some of the outputs from our partner project, LD4L-Labs, are included below; for the full list see LD4L Labs Outputs.
Linked data descriptions of library resources
...
Art and Rare Materials (ARM) BIBFRAME ontology extensions (includes versioning and change management best practicesmodeling documentation and ARM vocabularies)
Geospatial and Cartographic Resources Ontology (GCRO) (includes modeling documentation)
- LD4L Film ontology (and modeling documentsdocumentation)
- Performed Music Ontology (and PMO vocabularies and modeling documentsdocumentation)
- bibliotek-o (includes modeling documentation)
- Library of Congress BIBFRAME ontology (while developed prior to LD4P, BIBFRAME was further developed during the course of LD4P, with significant input from LD4P participants) and BIBFRAME “Consultations”: public feedback via the Issues tab in the github repository for the ontology https://github.com/lcnetdev/bibframe-ontology
Controlled vocabularies for use with ontologies
- public feedback mechanism
- Ontology versioning and change management best practices (from ARM)
- Art and Rare Materials (ARM) vocabularies
- Performed Music Ontology (PMO) vocabularies
Application profiles
- Art and Rare Materials (ARM) application profiles (used with VitroLib)
- Cornell Hip Hop LPs application profile (used with VitroLib)
- Recommendation for SHACL maintenance and development
- CEDAR templates for RDA book work and instance and digital repository self-deposit (create CEDAR account to use these)
Mappings to linked data
- Columbia University Library’s Art Properties metadata to ARM ontology
- MARC 382 field to Performed Music Ontology (PMO)
- Library of Congress' MARC 21 to BIBFRAME 2.0 (see also conversion tool and service below)
- MARC BSR to bibliotek-o
- Harvard Geospatial Library FGDC and Harvard Film Archive metadata to BF/bibliotek-o (see also conversion tools below)
- BIBFRAME-to-Solr (and SPARQL queries for Solr mapping)
- Tabular MODS-based metadata to BIBFRAME for Stanford sample collection (and Ruby conversion script)
Workflows for producing linked data
Tools
...
Visualization
...
Native linked data creation (Editors)
LD4L-Labs'
ThePrinceton's in-house annotation editor
App to fetch folder contents from CEDAR and post them to a triplestore
Repository
- Biblioportal ontology repository (library-specific implementation of Stanford University's BioPortal)
Tool requirements and evaluations
- Registry of Tools used in LD4P
- Requirements for and evaluations of form-based linked data editing tools (CEDAR, Library of Congress BIBFRAME Editor, VitroLib)
- Lessons Learned: VitroLib User Feedback and Usability Review
- User stories for converting MARC records to BIBFRAME
- User stories for converting MARC records to BIBFRAME (pdf) (Stanford workflows, use of converter, like converter requirements)
- Registry of Tools)
- Editor reqs/evals https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1nJXK_Un6NiaLV8cDYgovLExF7GzwjjO9T7ZdyaHGQ7g/ “Requirements for and Evaluations of Form-Based Linked Data Editing Tools”
Use cases for linked data descriptions
- Use cases for art materials
- Use cases for rare materials
- Use cases for cartographic materials
- Use cases for moving image materials
- Use cases for performed music
- Cartographic Materials use cases https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RxRKevDmZ0Ojs6r_QkCm9sGeiqdHIyC1ofia0hnWlL4/edit?usp=sharing
- Moving Image Materials Use Cases Initial use cases, May 2016
- Performed Music use cases https://docs.google.com/document/d/183USpuduYQIRP8WFZVFsFJo3goPD7sWbl3-oaCIVCYY/edit
Literature Reviews / Survey of existing work
- ArtFrame: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1dn-K3rMsafsLIxNQmAbrWT7zmCFM8FOOfG5LceYqrLI/edit?usp=sharing
- Cartographic https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1i6C_txLuZSayN0aaMlWW0Xs4m7nychARsOXr_mCO_vM/edit?usp=sharing
- Models for performed music https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/LD4P/Models+for+Performed+Music
Tutorials
Surveys of pre-existing work
- Cataloging Art Properties: A Literature Review for Columbia University’s LD4P Project
- Environmental scan of linked data efforts related to cartographic data
- Models for Performed Music
Tutorials
- Ontology modeling tutorial: from data model to ontology (developed for LD4P RareMat / ARTFrame Meeting)
- Discovering ontologies and instance data existing terms (developed for LD4P RareMat / ARTFrame Meeting)
- OWL tutorial (developed for LD4P RareMat / ARTFrame Meeting
- Modeling (from ARM: https://wiki.duraspace.org/download/attachments/90971798/Modeling%20Tutorial.pdf?version=1&modificationDate=1516639206988&api=v2)
- Discovering existing terms (from ARM: https://wiki.duraspace.org/download/attachments/90971798/Ontology%20Reuse%20and%20Ontology%20Design%20Patterns.pdf?version=1&modificationDate=1516284831720&api=v2)
- OWL (from ARM: https://wiki.duraspace.org/download/attachments/90971798/OWL%20Tutorial.pdf?version=1&modificationDate=1516639456962&api=v2)
- Publishing Library Authoritative Information as Linked Data (PowerPoint)
Meetings / presentations
Meeting outputs
- LD4 Workshop 2018
- LD4P / LD4L-Labs Community Input Meeting, April 24-25, 2017Add 2 community meetings
- In-Person Meeting of ARTframe + Rare Materials Ontology Extension (January 2018)
- In-Person Meeting of ARTframe + Rare Materials Ontology Extension (March 2017)
Presentations and publications