Page History

January 22, 2024

1. Handover: 
   1. Thank you Fredrik! Welcome Andreas Andersson
   2. Farewell Vitus! (& welcome Kalli!)
2. Subgroup Updates: subgroup meeting notes
   1. BIBFRAME Interlingua
   2. SHACL/DCTap 
3. Niklas presentation related to relationships
4. Short-term subgroup on relationships – discussion
   1. Call for documentation/background
   2. Call for members
   3. Decisions
      1. Share-VDE question: Should BIG prescribe use of BIBFRAME relationships?
5. Shanghai library session
6. Next time
   1. Matias on RDA mapping?
      
      

January 8th, 2024

1. Subgroup Updates: subgroup meeting notes

a) BIBFRAME Interlingua 

b) SHACL/DCTap 

      2. Consultant Group

Defining consultant role

      3. Relationships
Discussion led by LC

If using RDA relationships, does one need the map to bf or bflc or not? Confirm that implementers should map their data to BIG preference.
Tiziana to outline the example of rda relationship usage in Share-VDE as an example to inform the discussion (see some examples of svde data here: Examples of RDA properties application for BIG with a brief related document, reporting links to svde portal here: Tags 75x-77x-78x conversion_Examples_2

       4. Review/Update work plan for 2024

December 11th, 2023

1. BIG beyond April 2024 - Brief update on PCC support
2. Subgroup Updates
   

   a) BIBFRAME Interlingua 

   b) SHACL/DCTap

3. Consultant Group

November 27th, 2023

1. Meeting schedule - Dec 11 (end of 2023) -Jan 8th (resume 2024)
2. Subgroup Updates
   

   a) BIBFRAME Interlingua 

   b) SHACL/DCTap

3. Defining BIG beyond April 2024
4. Relationship question – If using RDA relationships in serial, does one need the map to bf or bflc or not? (Question for BIG)
   

November 13th, 2023

1. TOR update (confirmation) and anything else from PoCo
2. DCMI Conference update
3. Subgroup Updates
   

   a) BIBFRAME Interlingua 

   b) SHACL/DCTap

4. When to share initial outputs and when/how to onboard consultant group? 
5. Sample data check-in

October 23rd, 2023

1. TOR updates – discuss and vote for approval
2. Subgroup Updates
   

   a) BIBFRAME Interlingua 

   b) SHACL/DCTap

3. When to share initial outputs and when/how to onboard consultant group?
4. Sample data check-in

September 25, 2023

Only for chairs and subgroup chairs

1. Recap from BWE
2. 2023 Work Plan
3. DCTap/Shacl Group: Next steps and overall plan
4. Interlingua Group Next steps and overall plan
   
   

September 11, 2023

1. Welcome Kirk
2. Incoming chair: Xiaoli Li
3. BIG voted to change two co-chairs to Chair-Elect, Current Chair, Post Chair (following PoCo model)
4. Subgroup creation, leadership and membership
5. Interlingua Group report
   BIG approved work level to move into testing
   Interlingua group started work on instance level
6. SHACL/DCTap
7. Sample data – need approximate 100 description sets per implementation for textual monographs in Latin script
   Preferably in TTL serialization

July 24, 2023

1. Review work/outcomes from Interlingua subgroup discussions
   a) Should the interchange model and SHACL include bflc?
   b) Mapping into the Interlingua format if there are local variants
   c) Enforcing specific value vocabularies are out of scope due to international membership
   d) Blank nodes should be no barrier; rules need to understand and process both cases
   e) Need to define subgraph boundaries
2. To be discussed:
   a) Extending with other ontologies
   b) How to reliably indicate content type/work subclass/other option?

July 10, 2023

1. Review work/outcomes from the subgroup discussion:
   1. BIBFRAME Interlingua sheet
   2. Work - Issues and examples
1. BI Monograph Work - Level 1 draft
2. Questions and considerations 
2. Discussion on BIBFRAME Interlingua Adherence
3. When to bring in/constitute the consultant group/vendors?
4. Upcoming presentations
1. LD4
2. BWE
5. Co-Chair selection reminder

June 12, 2023

1. Next BIG co-chair 
2. Next BIG call scheduling (ALA conflict)
3. Work adminMetadata
4. Review sample data

May 22, 2023

1.  Complete guiding principles for use cases for interoperability
2.  Use to validate work level properties: BIBFRAME Interlingua Work - Issues and Examples
3.  Review sample data for required elements and needs for further samples/testing
4.  Next steps for subgroup on DC-Tap: Schedule meeting to complete work on bf:Work
5.  Upcoming events- Follow Up

May 8, 2023

1. Discuss and elaborate on use cases for interoperability
2. Review sample data for required elements and needs for further samples/testing
3. Next steps for subgroup on DC-Tap
4. Upcoming events - Follow Up

April 24, 2023

1. Further review for the BIBFRAME Interlingua Sheet specific to the Work

2. Issues and examples tracking

3. Opportunities for presentations at upcoming events

April 17, 2023

1. Review outcomes from the Work Shape Subgroup call
2. Discuss how to utilize examples to test interoperability for identified shape(s)
3. Next step for discussion and subgroup work
4. Presentations at upcoming conferences.

April 13, 2023

Meeting of First Pass at Work Shape Subgroup

April 3, 2023

1. Meeting Monday April 10th moved to Monday April 17th
2. Visualization/documentation generated from the existing SHACL rules which are in Sinopia development environment using the https://shacl-play.sparna.fr/play/ resource (Jim Hahn)
3. Subgroup Report & Review of Getting to Work document

March 13, 2023

1. Converting OWL to SHACL (Jim Hahn)

2. Determining next steps for DCTap usage and implementation

February 27, 2023

1. Review 2023 work plan (continued)
    Completed: 2023 Work Plan

February 13, 2023

1. DC Tap report (Fredrik Klingwall, Niklas Lindström, Jeremy Nelson)
2. 2023 workplan review
3. BIG representative needed on the PCC Task Group on BIBFRAME-to-MARC conversion (Volunteer: Wayne Schneider)

January 23, 2023

1. Follow up questions to the previous week’s presentations
2. Linked Data Summit Outcomes
   a. Discuss proposals for concrete next steps
   b. Focus areas for BIG:
   -- Exploration of Shapes in the validation of PCC BF data
   -- Further exploration of the interchange model; (new: csv manifest idea)
3. Linked Data Interest Group Discussion on BF Interoperability
   What’s your Bibframe data look like?  - Current State and Challenges of Bibframe Linked Data Interoperability
   Takeaways for our work

January 9, 2023

1. General overview of SHACL for BIG members (Jeremy Nelson)
2.  Fresnel (Niklas Lindström)

December 12, 2022

1. Strawperson Group output and the SHACL validation tool (continued)
   class/subclass, bflc namespace, labels from external sources
2. Issues posting to GitHub:
       https://github.com/LD4P/pcc-data-exchange/issues
3. How to approach standard entity shape identification

December 5, 2022

Strawperson Group output and the SHACL validation tool (Presentation with relevant links)

1. Feedback from testers

November 14, 2022

1. Presentation and hand-off from the Strawperson Group (25 min)
2. Linked Data Summit actions (15 min)
1. Discuss areas where BIG needs to focus and plan on next steps
3. How to approach standard entity shape identification (10 min)
1. Starting point from the Strawperson Group
4. Other updates and next call (10 min)

October 24, 2022

1. BIG participation in Linked Data Summit, Library of Congress, Nov. 7-8, 2022
2. Continue use case review and new use cases
3. BIG Cataloging Standards Background as a starting point for agreeing upon the starting point or base for interchange

September 26, 2022

1. BIBFRAME in Europe Workshop recap/takeaways
2.  Wiki updates
3.  Review Use Case group's work from Fall 2021 and Charles Riley's use cases
4.  Action items/next steps

September 12, 2022

1. Presentation for the BIBFRAME Workshop in Europe
2. Content ideas and subpages for the BIG Wiki

3. Presentation on Stanford implementation requirements (Nancy Lorimer) – deferred to future meeting

4. National Library of Sweden implementation (Fredrik Klingwall)
5. Next meeting 26 September

August 22, 2022

1. Welcome and introduction National Library of Finland
   
2. Exchange Shapes (Strawman Group) status
3. Review of survey responses/What are the flavors of bf: for consideration
4. Review work to date, add any further context or related projects
5. Need to loop in other vendors / idea of further consultants/vendor consultants
6. Identify subgroups/topics and priorities for different pieces (see charge for possible groupings)
7. Next call (potential agenda items)
8. BIG Wiki Available: https://wiki.lyrasis.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=249135298 

July 21st, 2022

1.  Introductions
2. Meeting times and frequency
3. Documentation and communication
4. Members, alternates and consultants
5. Review charge
6. Summary of recent efforts on interoperability
7. How/Where do we start?